Using lenses in the English classroom is very important in order
to build a better community, stronger reading skills, and greater understanding
of others. Teachers have always looked down on literary theories, as they
think that they are useless and that there are better things to teach about.
I have been reading the book Critical
Encounters In High School English: Teaching Literary Theory To Adolescents and
I have been exposed to very many different lenses. These lenses have made
understanding people unlike me a lot easier, whether I am doing this in my
reading or in eye-to-eye conversation. As a fifteen year-old freshman
that has trouble reading, I feel that many other students would love to learn
about these lenses. Without even realizing, I have increased my reading
skills greatly, as I saw after reading When
Kids Can't Read What Teachers Can Do, a book for teachers to help students.
These are some of the lenses that I think will help students
tremendously.
Gender Theory
Gender theory, also known as feminist theory, is something that
almost all students could use in our world right now. This lens is very
important to understand the opposite gender and how they think, especially as a
male. This helps students my age because we are becoming more
knowledgeable about the world and feminism is a very big topic that not many
people understand. Most of the students in my grade think very strongly
about one side, but don't understand why the other side thinks that way.
As Appleman says in her book, "There are at least four dimensions in
which feminist theory can transform students' reading" as we can learn to
think through the eyes of a female. Teaching this will completely change
the way we read books that are in the footsteps of an opposite gender.
This could help many struggling readers as it gives multiple
perspectives, and gives them more confidence in their reading as they won't be
as scared to read a book that doesn't have their same point of view.
Marxist Criticism Theory
Marxist criticism
theory, created by Karl Marx, is a lens that points out the different social
classes. This theory is a conflict theory as it shows the conflict
between the rich and the poor; dedicated philosophers have also studied it for
decades. "And Marxists critics are also interested in how the lower or
working classes are oppressed - in everyday life and in literature." (Literary
Theory and Schools of Criticism, N/A) This could be a very important theory to
teach students as in my area there aren’t too many families in the lower class.
It is always good to be able to think like a different social class, as
they are very prominent throughout the US. Marxism could also help many
students in their reading, as the students will begin to understand the lower
class and how they think compared to us students. Too many teachers find
that teaching this theory will be useless, as they believe all students already
get it, but I can tell many students in my grade are completely oblivious to the
other social classes, and think they have it just as easy as their peers.
Critical Race Theory
Critical race theory (CRT) is all about racism, and how it affects
literacy. This theory comes up in most literature, especially in older
literature. It is very important for students to realize how to apply CRT
into our everyday lives and in our reading. CRT is very helpful in order
to point out the struggles of different races and how different terms relate to
their culture. "In adopting this approach, CRT scholars attempt
to understand how victims of systemic racism are affected by cultural
perceptions of race and how they are able to represent themselves to counter
prejudice." (Literary Theory and Schools of Criticism, N/A) Many students would
be helped by this theory as it has them think like someone they aren’t and they
will realize how that race is oppressed. The amount of literature that
you could use CRT is limitless, and it could be a great way to show students
with different types of literature.
How To Apply The Theories
These lenses can
be incorporated into the classroom very easily, with a discussion or an essay
with the students looking through the opposite gender, social class, or race's
eyes. This discussion or essay could be based upon a book written in a
different point of view, or even any other type of literature in the that point
of view. Doing this will allow the students to think as the character
does, and get a better understanding of that group. After doing this the
students will get a much better grasp of this lenses, and how to apply them.
Another way that teachers can use this theory, is to have the students
find a piece of literacy to apply the lens to, and change it to a different
point of view. This will help the student with their ability to analyze
literature and apply this theory to real examples.
Literary Theories
are a great help to struggling readers. They give the readers another
perspective to read and think through, and will give the students more opportunities
with their literary texts. Within Dr. Beers' Think-Aloud Self-Assessment,
she asks if the student has been visualizing, predicting, commenting,
questioning, and more, in order to make sure the student is thinking aloud.
This ties into using lenses in the connecting portion, "I ask myself
how this is like something I've read or maybe a song I've heard. (Connecting)"
(Kylene Beers, 2003) if the students are learning lenses they can begin to
connect different texts and use similar lenses, from text to text. These
theories could also help excelling students as it gives them something to
experiment with, using different lenses. The students will be exposed to
many different styles of thinking and can build off of that, making their
reading and writing skills excel greatly.
Appleman, Deborah. Critical Encounters in High School English: Teaching Literary Theory to Adolescents. New York, Teachers College Press, 2009.
Beers, G. Kylene. When kids can't read, what teachers can do: a guide for teachers, 6-12. Portsmouth, NH, Heinemann, 2003.
Beers, G. Kylene. When kids can't read, what teachers can do: a guide for teachers, 6-12. Portsmouth, NH, Heinemann, 2003.
Dawson,
ReplyDeleteI am not familiar with Deborah Appleman's text so I'm exploring additional learning there, but I love that you are still connecting Kylene Beer's work in your blog posts.
Do you suppose that we could apply the different theories presented above to commercials on TV? Which theory seems to be the focus of this commercial "x" when compared to "y" and "z"? I think there is merit in further exploration of how it feels to walk in someone else's shoes in order to build empathy!
Thanks for giving me much more to read and think about! :-)
I do! There are so many different times when we could apply these lenses, including commercials, TV shows, and many more!
Delete